Why Don’t More Surgeons Offer the Open Preperitoneal Repair?

Why Don't More Surgeons Offer the Open Preperitoneal Repair?

Patients ask me this in consultations all the time. In my opinion, the answer has less to do with the operation and more to do with how surgeons are trained and how our field markets itself.

I trained as a general surgeon, and in my early years I did everything: gallbladders, appendixes, colon and breast cancer, parathyroids, and hernias. I loved it, but I learned quickly that I wanted to be an expert, not a generalist. Over the last 25 years I've narrowed my focus. For 15 years I've only done hernias, and for the last decade only inguinal and umbilical hernias.

I started out doing laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair, and it's a great operation. But when I learned the open preperitoneal repair almost 23 years ago, I came to understand the three-dimensional anatomy of the groin far better. I also found a repair that accomplishes the same goal without general anesthesia and without entering the peritoneal cavity. Why wouldn't I offer that to my patients?

I think more surgeons don't offer it for a few reasons. It's hard to learn and takes years. Because it's open surgery, it isn't marketed as "minimally invasive," so many surgeons have never heard of it. And laparoscopic surgeons have strong marketing and no outside reason to change. When I trained Dr. Nora Fullington, a laparoscopic hernia surgeon, it confirmed something I've long believed: it really takes a hernia specialist to learn this repair.

That's the bigger lesson for patients. The best outcomes, in my opinion, come from surgeons who focus on one thing and keep refining it. Before your hernia repair, ask your surgeon how many they do each year, which approaches they offer, and why they're recommending this one for you. You deserve the operation that's best for you, not only the one your surgeon happens to know.